10. TURKS & CAICOS

Readers’ Choice Rating: 79.4

Scenery: 77.9
Friendliness: 81.3
Atmosphere: 77.8
Restaurants: 71.5
Lodging: 84.2
Activities: 74.5
Beaches: 88.7

Readers describe these tropical islands as “exquisitely clean and unspoiled,” highlighting the “crystal blue waters” and “white powder sand.” Comb the beaches for their signature conch shells before stopping at reader favorite Jack’s Shack for a mojito.

Best 10 Islands in the Atlantic & Caribbean item0

9. ANTIGUA

Readers’ Choice Rating: 79.9

Scenery: 83.3
Friendliness: 82.5
Atmosphere: 80.8
Restaurants: 67.3
Lodging: 82.8
Activities: 74.0
Beaches: 85.6

This “vacation paradise” boasts “friendly people” and “a friendly environment.” As one reader put it, Antigua has so many beaches that “there’s somewhere gorgeous to spend every day of the year.”

Best 10 Islands in the Atlantic & Caribbean item1

8. VIEQUES

Readers’ Choice Rating: 80.2

Scenery: 92.3
Friendliness: 84.6
Atmosphere: 87.7
Restaurants: 57.4
Lodging: 70.5
Activities: 73.4
Beaches: 92.2

“Deserted, undeveloped beaches are the draw here” during the day, and at night, the bioluminescent bay is a “sight that is truly out-of-this-world.” “A real find,” say our readers; “Vieques is a place to get away from it all and just relax on the most beautiful beaches and be entertained and greeted by the friendly locals.”

Best 10 Islands in the Atlantic & Caribbean item2

7. ANGUILLA

Readers’ Choice Rating: 82.9

Scenery: 82.5
Friendliness: 84.8
Atmosphere: 85.4
Restaurants: 76.1
Lodging: 88.1
Activities: 72.1
Beaches: 90.8

“Need to unwind” or “reconnect with yourself?” Readers recommend Anguilla, where “the island’s untouched beauty is only surpassed” by that of the “world-class resorts.” “Lively inhabitants,” warm “island weather” and “simply stunning beaches” have our readers calling Anguilla “one of the last hidden paradises.”

Best 10 Islands in the Atlantic & Caribbean item3

6. ST. BARTS

Readers’ Choice Rating: 83.1

Scenery: 89.9
Friendliness: 69.9
Atmosphere: 86.2
Restaurants: 87.4
Lodging: 89.3
Activities: 74.5
Beaches: 87.2

In addition to “postcard beaches,” “beautiful villas,” and fish so fresh “you could taste,” our readers found St. Barts offered a “great cultural experience.” The “lovely getaway” gives visitors the impression that they’re “living a dream the entire trip.”

Best 10 Islands in the Atlantic & Caribbean item4

5. ST. LUCIA

Readers’ Choice Rating: 83.4

Scenery: 91.1
Friendliness: 85.0
Atmosphere: 84.2
Restaurants: 73.4
Lodging: 85.4
Activities: 80.3
Beaches: 81.2

St. Lucia truly is “a beautiful island with diverse scenery, from rainforests to beaches,” as one reader observes. Whether it’s the “black-sand beaches,” the “gorgeous tropical flowers,” or even the sweet “smell of mangoes” in the air that gets you, St. Lucia will soon have a “fond place” in your “heart.” Remember to visit the Pitons, twin volcanic peaks rising out of the ocean, which our readers found “magical at sunset.”

Best 10 Islands in the Atlantic & Caribbean item5

4. BRITISH VIRGIN ISLANDS

Readers’ Choice Rating: 84.2

Scenery: 93.6
Friendliness: 86.4
Atmosphere: 89.9
Restaurants: 71.6
Lodging: 84.9
Activities: 83.5
Beaches: 89.0

The “warm island breezes” and “clear waters” make these islands a “heaven” for sailing enthusiasts. Charter a captained vessel or go bareboating if you’re feeling independent, and then “dip in and out of remote coves and snorkeling spots with ease.” Make sure to check out the “lovely beaches” at Jost Van Dyke, the “volcanic islands” at Tortola, and the Baths at Virgin Gorda, a “must-see.”

Best 10 Islands in the Atlantic & Caribbean item6

3. NEVIS

Readers’ Choice Rating: 85.0

Scenery: 91.7
Friendliness: 88.9
Atmosphere: 88.9
Restaurants: 82.9
Lodging: 86.7
Activities: 74.1
Beaches: 81.3

Our readers think of Nevis as a “secret hideaway,” the “hidden gem of the Caribbean.” Though it’s a small island, they say “there’s more to do than you would think, and the greatest attraction is the natural beauty.” In addition to friendly people and great food, they also loved the “fantastic hotels” and the “many fantastic, affordable rental villas.” Overall, Nevis is a “warm, friendly, safe island” and a “great family destination.”

Best 10 Islands in the Atlantic & Caribbean item7

2. ST. JOHN

Readers’ Choice Rating: 85.8

Scenery: 94.1
Friendliness: 85.5
Atmosphere: 90.4
Restaurants: 73.3
Lodging: 82.0
Activities: 83.6
Beaches: 92.3

Readers find the “natural beauty” of St. John to be unparalleled. Most of the island is a preserved national park, allowing visitors to enjoy the “emerald green beaches” and exotic “native fauna and flora.” Bounce around the numerous cays in a kayak, or snorkel at Trunk Bay, where you might end up swimming “with a hawksbill turtle.”

Best 10 Islands in the Atlantic & Caribbean item8

1. BERMUDA

Readers’ Choice Rating: 87.1

Scenery: 93.1
Friendliness: 89.4
Atmosphere: 90.4
Restaurants: 77.5
Lodging: 84.1
Activities: 81.0
Beaches: 89.5

For a “fun blend of British, American, and Caribbean Culture,” Bermuda is the place to be. It offers “endless activities: historical sites, golf, scooters, superb shopping and dining, museums, gardens, perfumeries and aquariums, too!” Go for a snorkel or explore the many private coves to truly experience the island’s “lovely scenery,” which is highlighted by the “pink sand beaches and aqua blue waters.”

Best 10 Islands in the Atlantic & Caribbean item9

Via: Condé Nast